Guru Nanak at Mecca and historical evidence on turning of Kaaba


On demand of authenticated copy of eye witness account of Guru Nanak from Madain Project which looks on Abrahamic History & Archaeology of Islamic Archaeology, they referred my article to be accepted as its soft copy. The original script is available in Medina University.

Now all the critics need to hide their face in shame, someone may copy it and send it to fake historian Harjinder Dilgeer and Khalsa News too;

10711312_1470917376517350_1072278577_n

Evidence from Bhai Gurdas ji di war, writer of Sri Guru granth Sahib ji.

Dr. Zakir Naik once questioned and objected on turning of Kaaba by Guru Nanak ji. (Many others also object and say that non Muslims could never enter Mecca but they forget in 16th century, it was a desrted town and Guru Nanak ji was in guise of Muslim.

I may clear his doubts and all other curios readers that Kaaba has also turned thrice not only once  before visit of Guru Nanak ji.

An eyewitness account based on the diary of an Arabic writer who accompanied him

 Babania Kahania – Translator’s Note

During Guru Nanak’s journeys in the Middle East, a local author, Taajudin Naqshabandhi, joined Guru Nanak and remained with him for roughly one-and-a-half to two years. Taajudin documented his time with Guru Nanak in great detail. Four centuries later, a young man from Kashmir, Syed Mushtaq Hussain, chanced upon Taajudin’s handwritten manuscript while studying to become an Islamic scholar. This manuscript changed Mushtaq’s life. He converted to Sikhism and went on to become the renowned Sant Syed Prithipal Singh.

 In the absence of any facility available for copying the book in facsimile, Mushtaq Hussain took notes from Taajudin’s manuscript. He also took notes from another book, Twarikh-e-Arab, written by Khwaja Jainul Abdin, a Muslim author who also accompanied Guru Nanak during his travels to Mecca. Mushtaq’s notes later formed the basis of the Punjabi book,

Khwaja Jainul Abdin, the author of Tarikhe Arab, wrote the first-person account of Guru Nanak Dev ji’s Arabian journey. In his Arabic book, he writes, “I was with Guru Nanak Dev Ji when Guru Ji met Qazi (an Islamic religious judge) Rukn-ud-din.” As they came face-to-face, Rukn-ud-din offered his Salam, and the Guru replied, “Sat Shri Akal, Gurbar Akal” (The Lord immortal is the sole truth; the all-powerful timeless God). Rukn-ud-din asked, “Fala Alla Mazahbu,” meaning “which religion do you belong to?” The response was, “Abdulla Allah La Mazahabu,” meaning “I am God’s servant; I have no religion.”

Guru Nanak at Mekka

When Guru Nanak was sleeping near Kaaba, his feet were in direction to Kaaba. The attendents when noticed, they informed Qazi Rukunudin. He came there and pushed a kick in waste of Baba Nanak and asked, “who is this infidel (Kafir) sleeping by keeping his feet towards god’s home? At this the Guru replied,” I am an old man and tired. I do not know which side Alalh lives. kindly turn feet where Allah doesn’t reside.”

At this the Qazi hold his feet and turned his body but he was surprised to see that in whichever direction he turned feet of guru, the Kaaba was also turned.

 10428952_1471666996442388_1027875339_n

Bhai Gurdas ji gives account of visit of Baba Nanak at Mecca.

His sixth sense immediately warned him that this man is no ordinary person. And then he bowed before Guru Nanak.

Guru Nanak at Mekka-1

Many Muslims take offense with the reference that Jeevan (Qazi Rukunudin) saw the Kaaba move as he moved Guru Nanak’s feet to point them in a direction away from Kaaba. They claim that this could not have happened. However, there are many famous references in Islam which talk about the Kaaba moving.

1*****Hazrat Iban writes in his book Fatuhat Makih that he saw the Kaaba rise to crush him when he thought inappropriate thoughts about the Kaaba during the Hajj (Israr Shariat, part 2, page 74)

2*****Rabia, when passing through a forest on her way to the Hajj for the second time, saw the Kaaba coming towards her to welcome her. Rabia said, I was hoping to see God. I have no need for God’s house. If he were to walk towards me a length of a hand, I will advance a yard towards him. What do I do with the Kaaba? This doesn’t please me.

3*****Hazrat Ibrahim Azam went to Mecca, and was surprised to see the Kaaba missing. He thought his eyesight was failing him. He heard a voice which said, “there is nothing wrong with your eyesight, the Kaaba has gone to welcome a lady who is too feeble to walk to the Hajj” (Tazkiratul Awliayah, page 62).

4***** more evidences provided by Dr. Tarlochan Singh in his book ‘The Panjab Past and Present, Vol III, 1969. (Part I and II), The page is scanned to be viewed as follows:

Kaaba moved book by Dr. Tarlochan Singh

I may remind you that When Mohammad Sahib was proclaimed to be the last prophet, his wife Aisha protested and said to people, “say that he is the ‘seal of prophets’ but do not say there is no prophet after him.”

♣….About a  Hindu devotee Bhagat Namdev, it’s said that when he recited Lord’s name and turned his face in any direction, the DEODI, entrance of temple turned towards that direction wherever he turned his face.

A holy hymn in Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji narrates this historical evidence as JION JION NAAMA HAR GUN UCHRE BHAGAT JNA KAO DEHURA PHIRE !!

♣…..AND IN RAMAYANA, THE MOTHER SITA WHEN CRIED AND PRAYED TO MOTHER EARTH, a gorge was suddenly appeared, Sita entered in it and then it disappeared. That also proves that the nature is under control of Prophets/devotees or the Godman and works at their will.

♣…..In Tibet, Master Padmasambhav had placed the mountains on his left to the right and……..read here excerpts from the history and biography of master Padmasambhav written by his female disciple Yeshe Tsogyal, an authenticated source from the book,”THE LOTUS BORN”.(Page-60)

When the king Trisong Duetsen sent five emissaries to invite master Padmasambhav at Cave Yanglesho at the border of India and Tibet to tame the demons obstructing in building the Samye Monastery, master Padmasambhav received the message and went to Mangyul at the border of Nepal and Tibet where he met these emissaries who offered him Gold dust and circumbulated him in respect. 

The master was pleased by this and said, “i was checking whether or not the faith of Tibetans is fickle. For me all appearances are gold.” While saying this he stretched out his right arm in the direction of Sky Plain in Mang-yul, and the mountains on the left side shifted to the right. When he stretched his left arm to the west, the earth and rocks all turned into zi stones, agate, coral, gold, and turquoise, some of which he gave to the emissaries. Assuming a gaze, he made the Sun and Moon sink to the ground and, with a threatening gesture, he made the rivers reverse flow…….*

♣…..The Prophet Mohammad was also questioned to prove his Propecy by few Jewish, than he split the moon into two.

If the moon could split into two, mountains could shift from one side to other, the earth could split, allow Sita to enter and than gets normal as nothing happened, or the temple could move for Bhagat Namdev, why the Kaaba couldn’t turn to welcome the man of God Baba Nanak?

♣…..4. The Makkah Moved:

  Old Map of Baitul Muqaddas, Mecca

                                      Old map of Baitul Muqadass

The author of Sihayto Baba Nanak Fakir writes, “after bestowing the limitless flow of Naam in Baitul Muqaddas for three days, the master handed the preaching responsibility to Ibne Wahid (mentioned earlier), the respected member of the Sibi tribe. The master, Mardana and I then set out for Makkah. After several days we reached Kaaba in the evening. Kaaba is built outside Makkah, on one side.

At night, priests and caretakers go home.

The Baba (Nanak) circumambulated the deserted Kaaba14 carefully and then sat down on the great mussala15 of Sunni sect and started kirtan (spiritual singing).

14 Kaaba, is the small black structure in the depiction above, the large compound without a cover is Masjid Al-Haram. The dimensions of the Kaaba at 10m by 15m have not changed significantly over the history although it has been rebuilt around twelve times. The Masjid has gone through a lot of expansion. It started out at roughly 35m by 50m at the time of the Prophet, and currently it is oblong shaped at around 124m by 164m. At the time of the Guru the Masjid was roughly 50m by 150m .

In the third quarter of the night (around 3 am), the Lord ordered Mardana: “Brother, do not stop the kirtan.” The Guru then lay down pointing his head away from the Kaaba and
rested his feet against the wall of the Kaaba and fell asleep. All of us were surprised; if the Guru was going to fall asleep, why didn’t he also permit us to sleep?

The purpose of this instruction got apparent later: the master was going to wake up the masses of Makkah who had fallen into a deep slumber of delusions and superstitions.” At the end of the third quarter of the night, a caretaker16 with a broom approached from the city and started cleaning around the Kaaba. He was absorbed in singing kalma (verses of the Quran) at the top of his voice while sweeping the “House of
Allah” in service.

All of a sudden, he came across a man sleeping with his feet touching the walls of the Kaaba.

With a hoarse voice quivering in anger he shouted,

15 Mussala is the name of open space for prayer outside a mosque

16 In Vaaran Bhai Gurdas and in Janamsakhis, this caretaker is named “Jeevan”. Based
on the name, Bhai Vir Singh ji thinks that Jeevan was probably of Indian origin, and
either he or his parents settled in Makkah.

,“Azim Biazbun Kufrahu Haza Kufaruna كفارنا هذا كفرهم ذنب عظيم ” meaning, “These kafirs  (non-believers) are blasphemous beyond belief.”

He continued shouting more and more intolerable insults. But thinking objectively; he was right, as a Muslim, he was witnessing an ultimate sacrilege to the house of Allah.

When ignorance started crossing all limits, the merciful Guru sat up and addressed the caretaker in a loving voice:
“my dear good man! Why are you so angry with me? What have I done which is so bad that you are threatening me with fatwas of blasphemy?”

The caretaker thundered, “You Indians appear to be kafirs. Kafirs will definitely be put to death. You insult the house of Allah, and then you ask what you have done wrong! Mark my words! When the head Qazi (Islamic judge) shows up, he will tie you to these pillars and will tear your flesh with lashes. Then you will understand what you have done
wrong.”

The Guru tried explaining to him, but there was no effect on the caretaker’s soul which was soiled by hatred. Once the Guru realized that no words would permeate the man’s fouled intellect, he simply put his feet back and lay down again as before.

Taajudin writes that the caretaker started burning in rage and said, “Before I thought you had made an innocent mistake, now I know that you are committing this blasphemy on purpose to hurt my feelings. Remember! I will get the Qazi to put you to death unless you admit your guilt and ask for forgiveness.”

The embodiment of compassion the Satguru said very patiently, “Oh man of Allah! I didn’t do this to hurt your feelings. Instead, I am seeking knowledge from you. My friend, please move my feet in the direction where you don’t see Allah?”

The caretaker dropped the broom, and furiously dragged the Guru’s feet and spun his body until his head was touching the wall of the Kaaba and his feet were pointing in the other direction. Then he thanked Allah and said, “This is the house of merciful Allah. You ought to show respect here.”

Pleased with himself as if he had won a battle, the caretaker grabbed the broom, started reciting kalma loudly again, and resumed sweeping.

When he turned around, he found Guru’s feet touching the Kaaba again.
He was perplexed and started thinking that the Guru and his companions are harassing him, and the Guru has moved his feet again.

Ignorance is like a dark night. The caretaker leaped and dragged the feet away again. Once he picked up his broom and turned around, he saw the feet touching Kaaba again. Now he was beyond upset and said, “This time, I am going to drag you and throw you in that hole over there.”

–Listening to his ignorant diatribe, we started worrying that driven by his fire of hatred; the caretaker would commit some disrespect.

Burning in anger, he grabbed Guru’s feet and started dragging. Before, Kaaba moved when the caretaker was not looking. This time, the caretaker saw with his own eyes that Kaaba followed the Guru’s feet

17 I too saw this amazing sight three times with my own eyes. Having witnessed the miracle, the caretaker fell on the Guru’s feet and started begging,
“Taharana Ya Rabi Alaklubu Zulhalu” meaning, “Oh man of Allah, please grant me inner strength so that I can recognize you.”

The Guru sat up and said, “May you remember Allah”, and then went
into a trance.

The caretaker bowed again, hoping that the Guru would talk to him, and he could beg forgiveness for his mistakes. He tried a few times, but the   Guru remained in a trance.

Mardana started singing on his rebab (a string instrument),

17 Some Muslims take offense with the reference that Jeevan saw the Kaaba move as he moved Guru Nanak’s feet away from Kaaba. They claim that this could not have happened. However, there are many famous references in Islam which talk about the Kaaba moving:

 Hazrat Iban writes in his book Fatuhat Makih that he saw the Kaaba rise to crush him
when he thought inappropriate thoughts about the Kaaba during the Hajj (Israr
Shariat, part 2, page 74)

 Rabia, when passing through a forest on her way to the Hajj for the second time, saw the Kaaba coming towards her to welcome her. Rabia said, I was hoping to see God. I have no need for God’s house. If he were to walk towards me a length of a hand, I will advance a yard towards him. What do I do with the Kaaba? This doesn’t please me.

 Hazrat Ibrahim Azam went to Makkah, and was surprised to see the Kaaba missing. He thought his eyesight was failing him. He heard a voice which said, “There is nothing wrong with your eyesight, the Kaaba has gone to welcome a lady who is too feeble to walk to the Hajj” (Tazkiratul Awliayah, page 62). [52]

“As long as he says mine-mine, not even a single thing works. Once you give up I and mine (ego), the Creator comes and resolves all affairs – SGGS 1160.”
At some point, the Guru’s silence and the piercing message of Mardana’s singing overwhelmed the caretaker, and he got up and started running towards the town.
We got worried – what if he goes and incites a religious mob or a Mufti from the town?

I (Taajudin) started following the caretaker. He went to the Jama Masjid and climbed the tall minaret and started shouting in Arabic.

“Hear Ye Arabians; you have been claiming for centuries that the chamber of Kaaba is the house of Allah. Come and see today, Allah is sitting in his abode. Come behold his vision and fulfill your heart’s desires.”

The announcement worked like a talisman on the Arabs who are known to admire miracles and power. In no time, all the town’s men and women congregated in the masjid.

Soon Rukan-ud-din, the senior Qazi of Amir-e-Makkah (The Islamic Judge appointed by the ruler of Makkah) joined the crowd with his entourage.

After a quick religious hearing, the mullahs issued a fatwa of blasphemy. The decision was that it didn’t matter if the person in Kaaba was holiest of the holy. Once he made the Kaaba circle around himself, he committed the gravest blasphemy.

Upon hearing the fatwa, Arabs grabbed knives and axes and started screaming hack him! Kill him!

The caretaker, upon seeing the flames of ignorance got distressed. He ran through the mob and reached Rukan-ud-din at the front and pleaded “O great Mufti, I know that your decision will be correct. But please be mindful lest you commit a sacrilege. Indeed, he (Allah) himself is sitting in his own house in person.”
Jeevan’s devotion-filled words left a mark on Rukan-ud-din’s soul. The Guru’s blissful words to Jeevan “May you remember Allah” had cut through his ignorance and had washed his mind clean. Words coming from Jeevan’s hallowed mind were affecting Rukan-ud-din.
Rukan-ud-din asked Jeevan politely, “When you beheld the Creator, was he in a human form? Would I be able to see him and recognize him with my own eyes?”
Jeevan became emotional and said with tear-filled eyes. “Sire, it’s beyond my abilities to describe the majesty and glory of the Master. You have to see it to believe it. But, go there with love and respect. This mob, which is rushing there armed with ignorance, please
don’t take them with you.”
Rukan-ud-din agreed and said, “I am the authority here. I will order this mob disbanded. My good man Jeevan, I will take just a few pious men with me.” Taajudin wrote that Rukan-ud-din limited the group to one hundred fifty towns people and set out to Kaaba.

Zain-Ul-Abidin, the author of Twarikhe Arab (Arab History), wrote that when the group was walking towards Kaaba, somebody said, “The fakir at Kaaba should be crushed in an oil press.”

A Qazi named ‘Syed Ibne Walid’ quoted from the great book and said, “A person like that should be stoned to death.” Another Qazi added, “It would be appropriate to get him ripped apart by dogs after stoning.”

Rukan-ud-din kept listening to these men quietly.

Taajudin, the author of Sihayto Nanak Shah Fakir wrote, “I was there, I witnessed everything, and I heard everything.”

When the group was roughly a hundred steps from Kaaba, they stopped for further discussion. When they tried to walk again towards Kaaba, only Rukan-ud-din proceeded, the other could not, as if the ground had grabbed hold of their feet. Janamsakhi Bhai Bala also writes that earth had frozen the group’s feet lest they do something in disrespect and that only Rukan-ud-din got to Kaaba. Jeevan’s enlivening words were not lost on Rukan-ud-din his soul had started to soften up. Rukan-ud-din was not yet fully convinced, but definitely, some respect had taken hold in his heart.

If any one wishes to read the original text, may send me his/her email address, i may send him. You can mail me at doonsikh13@gmail.com
Please get your soul blessed by reading the eye witness account.

Presented by :-

Ajmer kesri

Ajmer Singh Randhawa.

 

75 Responses to “Guru Nanak at Mecca and historical evidence on turning of Kaaba”

  1. manjitsingh matharoo Says:

    very fine work (sewa) done by you most respected and brave Sikh scholar !!

  2. Gurinderpal Singh Josan Says:

    Excellent work ji, Guru mehar kare…

  3. Gurpreet Singh Says:

    not only kabba move but also when Bhagat Naam devji was pushed out of the temple. The temple moved 180 degrees to face Bhagat Naam Devji

    • asrandhawa Says:

      Agreed, gurbani says; JION JION NAAAMA HAR GUN UCHRE BHAGAT JNA KAO DEHURA PHIRE!!
      Thanks for reminding me one more evidence from Gurbani that any such sacred place can move to welcome nirankaar.
      My regards and guru fateh!

    • Sara Ansari Says:

      Infedil weren’t allowed in haram. Forbidden to enter.

      • asrandhawa Says:

        Thats for you humans not for Prophets or Nabis or the messenger’s of God. If Guru Nanak could freeze the mob, who was there to stop him? Kaaba welcomed him and turned to prove God is everywhere. You are an ordinary human being, so your vision is also smaller.

  4. GURMEL SINGH SIDHU Says:

    VERY INFORMATIVE ARTICLE BASED ON AUTHENTIC SOURCES.

  5. Jaspreet Singh Says:

    Very nicely understand in simple and easly way to read Punjabi THANKs…. For ur afforts …

  6. kskhu Says:

    Even Moslems can’t turn the Kaaba around

    • asrandhawa Says:

      This is not possible for an ordinary person but not impossible for a God’s man. Guru Nanak was himself almighty God. The Kaaba thus welcomed the master. But as you claim that Moslems can’t turn, it has already been explained in this blog as it already replaced from its original place thrice before visit of Guru Nanak ji.

    • faizan Says:

      *spelt Muslim and no we can’t we are only human but I respect all religions and I believe god can do anything for certain people

  7. Jas Johal Says:

    With all due respect.. Guru Nanak never once claimed .. in scholarly text or reference He was God. He was a Guru and a teacher of God’s name… The movement of the Kabba is what’s considered a Miracle which goes against the Sikh teaching of idolism and supernatural apparitions.. a lot of the early stories seem extremely hypocritical to me personally and I feel are metaphorical rather than Fact. Just my opinion, not to offend anyone.

    • asrandhawa Says:

      Agreed but where i or anybody calls Guru Nanak ji as God? but you are certainly wrong as life of Guru Nanak is full of miraclees, Just read any janamsakhi and see it yourself.
      In Islam the conditions to be called a Nabi or Paiganbar is defined as follows;
      1- Karamatun, means he should be able to do miracles,
      2- kitabun, means he should have a book of holy hymnes or the words of God, and
      3- Umatun, means he should have large number of believers in him.
      ਪੈਗੰਬਰ ਦੀ ਪਛਾਣ ਤਿੰਨ ਚੀਜ਼ਾਂ ਸਦਕਾ ਹੁੰਦੀ ਹੈ, ‘ਰੱਬੀ ਬਾਣੀ ਦੀ ਕਿਤਾਬ, ਚਮਤਕਾਰ ਕਰਣ ਦੀ ਤਾਕ਼ਤ ਅਤੇ ਚੇਲੇ!’
      Do the Guru Naanak not fulfill these conditions? It’s the reason he was honored by Peer Dastgir and a gurudwara is built in Baghdad (Iraq) o commemorate visit of Guru Nanak and his meeting with Peer Bahlol (Dastgeer).

      • Asar Akram Says:

        Bismillah.
        Hazrat Guru Nanak Sahib A.S. was an extremely holy friend of Allah Pak. He was not a prophet, as Prophet Muhammad S.A.W.W. was the seal of the prophets. But he did something which almost no prophet (apart from Prophet Muhammad S.A.W.W., and perhaps Prophet Ibrahim A.S., none) did: He entered the Personal Presence of God in Aalam-e-Ahdiat and communicated with him. He was extremely exalted in status and followed neither Islam, Hinduism or even Sikhism but the original religion of God, Deen-e-Ilahi. Thus, insulting him will take you to Hell and erase all your good deeds because he was from the Walis and the extreme lovers of God.

      • asrandhawa Says:

        The seal is for Arab not whole world. It may apply in Arab countries not is rest of world. Guru Nanak is the master of universe. It was experienced by Musllim scholar in 1920 and he embraced Sikh religion. Heis known as Sayyad Parithipal Singh Bedi. He was son of a Maulvi, he witnessed when he saw all the powers of Islamic sorcery in Qoran were failed before a common religious Sikh person. He recognized guru Nanak more than us. So he left Islam and became an admirer of Guru Nanak and walked on true path of humanity shown by Lord of the Lords Guru Nanak.
        Guru Nanak gives peace and salvation, we don’t pray PBUH for him. We need not.

  8. Raj. A. Pillai Says:

    Absolutely fascinating story. It says Mushtaq Hussain took notes from Taajudin’s original manuscript. I’d like to know if the notes have survived through time and whether they have been translated into English and if they’re available? Can anyone please enlighten me. Thank you.

  9. Karanjit Singh Says:

    Beautifully written, an amazing piece of history which will remain with me forever and a piece of history that will be taught to my children when they are older.

    • asrandhawa Says:

      Thanks karanjit Singh ji, my aim to translate it in punjabi was meant the same. It’s an eye witness recorded kept in Library of Medina University which takes me in lotus feet of nirankar. I find no words to express my gratitude, just amazed to read this article. Waheguru may always bless your family.

  10. Manjoat Says:

    Would you happen to know if the original manuscripts of Siyahto Baba Nanak Fakir and Twarikh-e-Arab, are still available and where. If the original are available have the been translated? Thank you.

    • asrandhawa Says:

      Thanks for your comment, as per this translation from the article written by Principal Syaed singh Bedi ji, the manuscripts were translated by him, i translated this from english to Punjab.But if you too have, please inform. Or please call me 0091-9818610698.(New Delhi).
      My regrads.

  11. Hash111 Says:

    The narrations you have taken such as that of raabia are totally false and it was more of sufism rather than islam no muslim believes in that what she said. Sufism has no place in islam. And brother what you are referring as famous references are not at all islam. Islam only teaches what the quran says and what the hadees of the prophet is. Anything which goes against these two have no place place in islam so brother kindly correct your knowledge about islam

    • Asar Akram Says:

      Bismillah.
      All the narrations @asrandhawa spoke of were correct apart from the fabricated one of Bibi Aisha R.A. You were also wrong by saying that Sufism has no place in Islam. Sufism is the essence of Islam. These serpentine scholars have ruined real Islam. But you were right by saying anything that goes against the Quran Majeed or Hadees Shareef is truly not connected to Islam.

      • asrandhawa Says:

        What is Sufism or Islam is not my point of view. I quoted evidences from Hindu, Buddhist and Islam on moving of buildings or the depart of Land. Kaaba too moved, and that’s proved.
        Thank you

  12. lakhbir Says:

    I love that t

  13. Very beautiful | Karma Lane Says:

    […] https://asrandhawa.wordpress.com/guru-nanak-at-mecca-and-historical-evidence-on-turning-of-kaaba/ […]

  14. hardip singh badhan Says:

    Dhan dhan guru nanak dev ji ,naam japo kirat karo vandh shako

  15. Shamer Says:

    Guru nanak ask to move his feet were god is not there, so when his feet turn,kaaba also move. It shows that god is everywhere, we cannot limit god where He will not be somewhere or what. No big deal, eventhough the kaaba moved, its just a direction for us to pay. Seriously, no big deal.

    • asrandhawa Says:

      Through this incident of turning kaaba and the conversation in between Maulwis and Guru Nanak, Guru Nanak successfully gave this message that God is everywhere not sitting at one place.

  16. Haris Bin Ashraf Says:

    Sir, with all due respect.. You must know that the authentic sources of Islam are only Quran and Hadith (true narrations of sayings and acts of Holy Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). The books you have mentioned i.e. Israr-e-shariyat and all have been written by common people and cannot be considered authentic with regards to religion.

    • asrandhawa Says:

      Dear Haris Bin Asraf; Hadiths and Qoran were written before 1200 years ago but Guru Nanak visite Mecca 550 years ago only. How could there be any mention of his visit in these religious books? This evidence from said book is historical evidence not the religious. For your kind information, authenticated evidences of his visit and turning of Kaaba to welcome him, are avilable in Sikh manuscripts.

    • Nur Says:

      You are so true sir…
      Out of sudden why now everyone is bringing up this issue.. ?it’s is clearly stated in Quran about Kaabah… as a muslim we must respect all the religions. But this statement given is purely false. No evidence.. just like a storybook.. enough of having alot of issue about religions globally… stop creating a new issue as it will course unnecessary debates n prob.. thank you

      • asrandhawa Says:

        Mr. Nur, I am a Sikh and whatever evidences provided in article are either provided from Sikh history through authanticated sources or revealed by Muslim scholars. I don’t mind if a debate starts. Every word written in this blog are written with utmost care and truthfully to the best of my knowledge. Foolish are those who are biased and wear glasses f relegion colored in fanatism
        Thanks for visiting the blog and for your valuable comment.

    • asrandhawa Says:

      Here is one more authenticated evidence from Qoran:
      The prophecy about Sikhism in the Quran Majid.
      The holy Qoran Majid foretell on the creation of the Khalsa-the pures.
      The prophecy about Sikhism in the Quran Majid:

      “Ya ayyuha allatheena amanoo man yartadda minkum AAan deenihi fasawfa ya’tee Allahu biqawmin yuhibbuhum wayuhibboonahu athillatin AAala almu’mineena aAAizzatin AAala alkafireena yujahidoona fee sabeeli Allahi wala yakhafoona lawmata la-imin thalika fadlu Allahi yu’teehi man yashao wallahu wasiAAun Aaaleem.”Quran, Surat Al-Maidah, 5:54,

      Meaning, “O’ you religious people, when you move away from the faith, Allah will create a nation of the pure. Allah will love this nation, and they will love Him. You will know of this nation by the sign that they will be harsh on non-believers and gentle with believers. They will give up their lives for the path of Allah and will remove tyranny and will not be afraid of any criticism. [Then Allah says,] I will bestow my favor and power on whoever I please.” Quran, Surat Al-Maidah, 5:54,

      English translation by Sahih International,

      “O you who have believed, whoever of you should revert from his religion – Allah will bring forth [in place of them] a people He will love and who will love Him [who are] humble toward the believers, powerful against the disbelievers; they strive in the cause of Allah and do not fear the blame of a critic. That is the favor of Allah ; He bestows it upon whom He wills. And Allah is all-Encompassing and Knowing.”

      In the name of religion, only Muslims take the lives of innocent people of others faith. Is it justified? What will happen if people of other faiths or the govts. of powerful nation takes a unique stand to eliminate islam from Earth? It will take few seconds to them. So please stop the killing of people of others faith. I slam may suits you, you may profess it but don’t impose your religion upon others as they too believe in existance of God and we do not find any difference in God or Allah.

      You may call a Rose by any name, it won’t stop its fragrance.
      https://asrandhawa.wordpress.com/2018/07/03/the-prophecy-about-sikhism-in-the-quran-majid/:

      • Asar Akram Says:

        Bismillah.
        You are correct. But Sikhs and Muslims are both common. The prophesied nation cannot refer to a religion in any case, except Deen-e-Ilahi.

      • asrandhawa Says:

        May be so but that religion is abolished with Akbar, I don’t see any more sign of Deen-e-Ilahi.

  17. Mohinder Singh Chana Says:

    Very instring research be good to have a documentary film on this subject

  18. Anilraj Singh Says:

    After doing some raincheck around with some very well versed souls (with all due respect to your effort veerji), probably the logical conclusion, whereby the point to be noted herr is those who heard Guru ji in their minds saw the move as a change of thought. If all had seen the Kaaba move, it wud have been the end of Islam, as all would have converted, no?

    • asrandhawa Says:

      Sorry for a late reply as i missed your comment. You might be aware of preaching of Gita at Kurukshetra where Sri Krishna preaches divine knowledge to Arjun in battlefield. Don’t forget they were standing in the middle of both armies. none heard Sri krishna other than Arjun only.
      Sanjay could hear it and described to Dhritrahtra sitting 100 miles away at Hastinapur.
      Sanjay was blessed so he could hear but why nobody else in battlefield hear the preaching of Gita? And nobody fought until the preaching was not over as time was made to hault? Is it possoble?
      So Mr. Anilraj Singh ji, had others also heard, the battle in Kauravas and Pandavas would have not fought, both could be blessed by this divine knowledge why only Arjun was benefitted? Why Lord Krishna was kind upon him?
      So whatever happened at Mecca and why islam not stopped, might be known to Guru Nanak. If he could turn the Kaaba, made the attackers statues or if he could go anywhere at his will,m he could end the Islam also but he preached Muslims also in Guru Granth sahib ji to be a true Muslim.
      Gurus were not against any race or religion but preached that almighty Akal Purakh or the Allah is not bound at one place only but he is everywhere so by turning kaaba, he proved it.

      • Ali Says:

        You have provided references as you have said that those reference are from Muslims scholar. …can you justify these references and please provide proof of references and proof of existence of Muslim scholar mentioned above.

      • asrandhawa Says:

        Mr. Ali, Either search the said documents in Medina university or go to heaven to meet the scholar there.The answer is already in the article, read it number of times and see yourself but can’t say if your biased mind will accept it.

  19. Jashan Says:

    Non-muslims were not allowed to enter in Mecca and also non-hindus were not allowed to enter Jagannath Temple.
    But Sarab-kala samrath Baba Nanak entered both the places.

  20. RAJAGOPALAN Says:

    Yes no doubt others may not accept it but surely it’s a fact.

  21. Lucky Kaur Says:

    Amazing post! You have shared some wonderful information here. Guru Nanak ji was one of the most inspirational guru all over the world. Celebrating Guru Nanak Jayanti is a day to honor him.
    Lucky Kaur

  22. Sohan Lavande Says:

    Very beautiful and very interesting. Thank you for presenting this for us.

  23. asrandhawa Says:

    1000s Miles travel in a blink of eye by Guru Nanak ji (Eye witness account)
    The Author of the travels (Tajuddin) is blessed by the touch of the Guru’s feet.

    1000s Miles travel in a blink of eye by Guru Nanak ji (Eye witness account)

  24. asrandhawa Says:

    If Moon could split into two, why kaaba couldn’t move to welcome Guru Nanak ji

    If Moon could split into two, why kaaba couldn’t move to welcome Guru Nanak ji

  25. Ronn Chin Says:

    Please sent me the original text, I am interested in it, thank you sir.

    • asrandhawa Says:

      How could i give the original text which was read in 1920 at Medina University by a Muslim youth Mushtaq Hussain?
      Babania Kahania – Translator’s Notes During Guru Nanak’s journeys in the Middle East, a local author, Taajudin Naqshabandhi, joined Guru Nanak and remained with him for roughly one-and-a-half to two years. Taajudin documented his time with Guru Nanak in great detail.
      Four centuries later, a young man from Kashmir, Syed Mushtaq Hussain, chanced upon Taajudin’s handwritten manuscript while studying to become an Islamic scholar. This manuscript changed Mushtaq’s life. He embraced Sikhism and known as a Sikh scholar Sant Syed Prithipal Singh.
      In the absence of any facility available for copying the book in facsimile, Mushtaq Hussain took notes from Taajudin’s manuscript. He also took notes from another book, Twarikh-e-Arab, written by Khwaja Jainul Abdin, a Muslim author who also accompanied Guru Nanak during his travels to Mecca. Mushtaq’s notes later formed the basis of the Punjabi book, Babe Nanak di Baghdad Pheri (visit).

      Source: https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B39vxC8IGIWFbTlST1ctX2psdEk/edit

  26. गुरु गोविंद सिंह ने काबा को अपनी जगह से हिला कर बताया था कि अल्लाह हर तरफ है. Says:

    […] ताज्किरात्कुल अवलियाह में लिखा हुआ है कि जब हज़रात इब्राहिम अज़म मक्का गए तो उन्होंने देखा कि काबा अपनी जगह पर है ही नहीं. उनको लगा कि उनकी आँखों में कोई दिक्कत है पर उसी वक़्त उन्हें एक आवाज़ सुनाई दी कि ‘तुम्हारी आँखें ख़राब नहीं हुई हैं काबा एक महिला का स्वागत करने गयी है क्योंकि वह महिला हज करने में असमर्थ थी’. […]

  27. Ronn Chin Says:

    Thank you for sharing, I would like the oringal text , would kindly send it to me. E-mail ,chinronn@yahoo. com

  28. simar singh Says:

    I am grandson of mushtaq hussain ( syed prithipal singh ji )
    Who took notes from library of madina ajmer singh ji can i get you contact number i want to conatct you my whatsapp +91 8847385784

    • asrandhawa Says:

      Its a pleasure for me, thanks

      • Amarjeet Singh Says:

        It is a pity that the original manuscript which syed sahab had in his possession is not traceable otherwise it would have been wonderful. It would be interesting to investigate if there are still some secret Arab admirers of guru nanak in the places mentioned in the book.

  29. Amarjeet Singh Says:

    It is a pity that the original manuscript which syed sahab had in his possession is not traceable otherwise it would have been wonderful. It would be interesting to investigate if there are still some secret Arab admirers of guru nanak in the places mentioned in the book.

  30. inderjit Singh kohli Says:

    May I access 2 d original manuscripts copy

  31. S Manmohan Singh Says:

    Fantabulous , informative document

  32. Mohammad Khan Says:

    Thanks for the article I mean no disrespect but there is no proof that the Kaba has ever moved . Of course you as a Sikh believe in this story written in the SGGS but there is no proof whatsoever in your words . The Kaba has never moved it was always situated in the centre of the earth. It is on the middle of the globe. Regarding guru Nanak quote move my feet in the direction that you don’t see Allah … this is not true by itself. Muslims do not claim that they see Allah in the Kaba or anything . People use to climb on top of the Kaba and give Adhan. The Kaba is just the direction they pray in . I see you have quoted some Muslim quotes about the Kaba moving maybe that was spiritually but regarding physicallly the Kaba has never moved. If you believe it has please provide any proof to the contrary. Any historical proof will do but it has to be legetimate . I look forward to your reply .
    Thank you so much

  33. Mohammad Khan Says:

    Thankyou for your prompt reply. I asked for evidence which there is none, just an alleged letter . I mean no offence but such a miracle happened and theres no external evidence or anything to prove what is written in sikhi. The kabah being removed and assembled again haopened when the prophet was born and there is evidence for that. But there is no evidence whatsoever of the kabah changing any direction at all. Thousands of visitors go to the kabah every day and theres no ine else to collaborate what is written about Nanak moving the kabah. I mean common, be realistic my friend. Furthermore re-reading your comment the arabic qoutes the arabic is tremendously wrong i mean what Tjuddin writes “taharana…. “ lol my friend. This proves that this is fake. And all the evidence you give qoutes 1-4 is all wrong.. theres no evidence to prove any of this. Im sorry for hurting your feelings but fact is there is no evidence. I also looked into khawajah jainul abdin and the book thareeq arab … there is no book like that.. furthermore outside sikh literarure there is no Mr Abdin. I would be happy to debate you if you would like. I am fluent in both arabic and hindi/punjabi and english.
    I just wanted to ask a question… it is a different topic.. when Guru Nanak replied to the guard in Makkah.. laa madhab… that means he is of no religion .. and he says he is Abdullah.. that means he is not messenger or initiator of a faith ? Correct me if im wrong.. but he should say i am a man of Allah and he has given me the divine message or something like that … ? Or proclaim hes a prophet.

    • asrandhawa Says:

      Mr. Khan, Good morning. Whether A din having any authenticated place in Islam or not, its not my concern. He claimed that he was with Guru Nanak when Kaaba was moved. You asked me if there is any evidence in Sikhi? Yes there is mentioned in Manuscript written by Bhai Gurdas ji. The honor to pen down original Guru Granth Sahib ji also goes to him. In which direction it moved, is also described in a map shown in that book. You say that you have seen the original book Tawrikh-e Arab, and you couldn’t find it, please contact Medina University and make a request, if they provide you copy of the original. Muslims will never accept, if they accept, it will be like accepting supremacy of Sikh religion upon Islam like Hindus claim every invention in the world, having been narrated in their manuscripts. Its good if you know Panjabi language, you must be aware of 4 travels of Guru Nanak, its already mentioned in them. The historical Gurudwara or a memorial of Guru Nanak is also built in Baghdad. Good bye.

      On Mon, Dec 20, 2021, 3:18 AM Voice of Sikh nation wrote:

      >

  34. Mohammad khan Says:

    Furthermore the whole story about guru nanak meeting phir dastaghir is all false. There is around 300 years difference between them. I have been researching sikh history and found out it has no scientific way of sorting out actual history with mythology. Lots of sikh scholars are calling for a thorough analysis of guru nanaks life with verifiable evidence. Im sure you know islam has a process which was enforced . Hence comparing the two would be a no brainer. Peace my brother.

    • asrandhawa Says:

      Sikh religion is the purest religion, neither it has any falsehood nor the mythology like Islam. Your Mohammad said that when he visited hell, he found majority of inhabitants there were women.
      So he went to hell.
      Next, if women in hell are high numbered, how could a Jihdi will get 72 angels in heaven where women are in less number?
      Whether your Mohammad will allow the women from hell to enter in heaven and give a company to his men?
      Scientifically the Moon can’t split in two parts, how did Mohammad did it? Its impossible.
      And the next is when did both of these parts joined again to form one moon?
      Any account?
      Answer these question, before I ask you more.

      • Mohammad khan Says:

        Thankyou for your reply. Yes my friend all questions are appreciated. Muhammad pbuh went to heaven and hell its written in the seerah of the prophet pbuh. I will answer your questions as best as i can, though i am no islamic scholar by all means !
        The majority of women in hell that he was referring to are women in this world. Although the hadeeths dont give reference to how many women at all.
        The jana hur promised are not women of this world. It does t give any reference to any jihadi at all getting jana hur,,, it says men living in paradise will het jana hur as desired by them in the Quran. It diesnt make any reference to 72… though still that answers your question.
        Mohammad pbuh does not have any say as to whether the women or the men are going to hell or heaven. This is done by Allah.. on judgement day your good deeds and bad deeds will be weighed and that will decide.
        Regarding the moon splitting that is speaking about a future event and scholars say this will be done in the future. The Quran verse speaksabout the day of judgement approaching , although some muslims have interpreted it as an event that happened in his time, many oppose it. From the purest source the Quran, it is talking about a future event.

        Although there have been instances of people seeing the moon split, not in Mohammads time but centuries after. A quick search gave me this in Wikipedia

        One hour after sunset on 18 June 1178, at least five men in southern England reported having witnessed an unusual phenomenon in the sky. According to the monk Gervasio, chronicler of the Abbey of Christ Church in Canterbury, the upper horn of the crescent Moon was split in two.

        I believe this answers your questions. Furthermore i notice you have not answered my questions at all. Hence, i have researched the sikhi history, there was no scientific analysis dine on what statements were true or false regarding Guru Nanaks life story. Obviously as a sikh you have to favour your faith but when it comes down to it, many simh stories can be proved wrong, such as turning of the kabah, nanak meeting imam dastaghir . I am not saying this, your sikh scholars are saying this .
        I do not want to hurt your feelings my brother. Me , on the other hand, i am a free thinker i believe in God and the last day and his messengers but what diesnt make sense to me i dint believe as long as someone can provide adequate proof i dint change my thinking. You have failed to provide any evidence regarding statements in this article,.
        Furthermore my friend the qoute you gave about Aisha rduh saying that the prophet never said ge is the last messenger, thats absoluteky false. In the Quran and hadeeth it is stated that he is the last seal of the prophets.
        Peace my brother, enjoy your day. God bless you and your family.

      • Asar Akram Says:

        Bismillah.
        Please! Do not insult the Holy Prophet S.A.W.W. like this. The essence of Islam is the purest religion possible. But religion is meaningless! Both the Holy Prophet and Nanak Sahib were holy people of God. But no holy person can reach the Prophet’s rank. If you say that Nanak Sahib A.S. is the Holy Prophet for you then you are not wrong. But if you say that Nanak Sahib is superior to the Holy Prophet then you are being cursed by Nanak Sahib A.S.! Please do not insult the Holy Prophet, who is the holiest figure after God. He is exalted beyond words.
        وَإِنَّكَ لَعَلَىٰ خُلُقٍ عَظِيمٍ ‎﴿٤﴾

        And indeed you possess the greatest character.
        – Surah Qalam, Verse Four

      • asrandhawa Says:

        Whatever i have written, are the viuews from Sikh philosophy. You, being a Muslim may honor your prophet as superior but we consider Guru Nanak only. Kaaba too turned to welcome Guru Nanak ji.

  35. Mohammad khan Says:

    Morning. Thanks my friend about the comments. I asked for any evidence outside of sikhi. Hence you have been unable to come up with anything. I illustrated the poor arabic written in the article and that is not written by a person who speaks arabic at all. Maybe knows a few words, but taharana … doesnt make sense at all.. it isnt what you translated it is .. or anywhere close. So really this story about an arabic speaker accompanying guru Nanak and the kabah turning seems impossible.
    I am sorry my friend but this whole kaba turning is a lot more unlikely than likely at all.
    Regarding supremacy of sikhi over islam. My friend this is a no brainer. I dont need to tell you as you will know yourself…islam is the only religion that will tell you that you can prove islam wrong. Im aware sikhi does nit have anything like this. Islam is the worlds fastest growing faith , even attracting sikhs worldwide. Thank you peace my brother. Anyway my message to you and myself as well is that dont believe anything until you have been provided evidence and done analysis . Peace my brother .

  36. Manmeet Singh Says:

    If possible, let me know or provide the book on cast. So that I will go through it thoroughly.

  37. Manmeet Singh Says:

    Very interesting and knowledge full. The script is original and I respect the main writer sir Tajuddin who documented it well. Also I respect Syed prithipal singh who has awarded it with most so that it shoukd come in the knowledge of all.
    Sardar Ajmehar singh ji, scholars like your are our assets. Chardikalan

  38. Jasvinder singh Says:

    Very well told. Need to be spread across the globe. Also needed to find traitors within quom who question all historical sakhies

  39. Joginder Singh Says:

    Very good work ji Baba nanak Mehar kre ji🙏

  40. Barinderjit Singh Says:

    Excellent briefing …full of knowledge…

  41. Sunil P.C. Says:

    Thank you very very much for the references, especially about the Kaaba coming to Bhaarath.

Leave a comment